La Conseillante, déja particulièrement appréciée par les professionnels bordelais et importateurs du monde entier, semble faire l'unanimité auprès des dégustateurs. Quelques exemples :

- Robert Parker, 93-95+ / 100 : "The finest La Conseillante since 2000..."

- Jancis Robinson MW, 17,5+ / 20 : "Zesty wine which has a cocktail of fine fruit on the mid palate but masses of pretty inky tannins on the finish."

- Jean-Marc Quarin, 17-17,25 / 20 : "Voilà de l’éclat aromatique ! C’est un des La Conseillante les plus denses que je connaisse..."

- Decanter (James Lawther MW), 18,5 / 20 : "La Conseillante maintain's its fine, elegant style bolstered by an added layer of fruit and reserve..."

- Neil Martin, 22 / 25 : "Lots of character here, powerful and yet very controlled. Excellent."

- Wine Spectator (James Suckling), 92-94 / 100 : "Full-bodied, with lovely silky tannins and a long finish. Has the potential for a classic rating."

- Berry Brothers, 19 / 20 : "Hot on the heels of their outstanding 2004, this is set to be one of the must-haves of the vintage."